Why Do Real Estate Agents Fail? 9 Reasons New Agents Quit in Year One

Why Do Real Estate Agents Fail

Why do real estate agents fail? Usually it comes down to cash and clients. New agents pay fees, insurance and marketing costs from their first week, but commission only arrives after a deal closes, and many have no steady way to find buyers and sellers. In 2025, 52.7% of the 69,728 agents at the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) closed zero transactions, according to Redatum data cited by Real Estate Magazine.

Talent is rarely the missing piece. The agents who last plan their money, build a lead routine and keep learning after they register. That last part is where good real estate agent training helps, because weekly sessions on marketing, negotiation, pre-construction and mortgages fill the gap between passing the exams and running a real business. Below, you will find the Ontario numbers, the nine reasons agents quit and a month-by-month plan for getting through year one.

How Many Real Estate Agents Fail or Quit in Ontario?

No regulator in Canada publishes a “failure rate” for agents. The figures that circulate online, such as “87% fail within five years”, come from US sources that do not show their method, so they are left out here. Ontario does have solid data on who joins, who leaves and who closes deals.

What was measuredFigureSource
RECO registrants at Dec. 31, 2025111,332 (down 1.36% from 112,865)RECO Annual Report 2025
New registration applications, 20254,671 (6,329 in 2024)RECO Annual Report 2025
Registrations terminated, 20256,457 (about 5.8% of registrants)RECO Annual Report 2025
TRREB agents at Dec. 31, 202569,728Redatum data in Real Estate Magazine
TRREB agents with zero deals in 202536,738 (52.7%)Redatum data in Real Estate Magazine
TRREB agents with 20 or more deals in 2025560 (0.8%)Redatum data in Real Estate Magazine

Sources: RECO Annual Report 2025; Real Estate Magazine opinion column by David Ursino, April 20, 2026.

Three things stand out in these numbers:

  • More people left than applied: RECO terminated 6,457 registrations in 2025 and received 4,671 new applications. RECO says the terminations were mostly voluntary non-renewals and unpaid insurance premiums.
  • No official retention rate exists: The closest proxy for a real estate agent retention rate in Ontario is RECO’s 2025 figure: terminations equal to about 5.8% of all registrants in one year.
  • Deals are concentrated: About one in 125 TRREB agents closed 20 or more transactions in 2025, while more than half closed none.

The market adds pressure. TRREB reported 5,603 home sales in the GTA in October 2026, down 7.9% from October 2025, with an average price of $1,024,108. Fewer sales spread across tens of thousands of agents mean a new agent has to work harder for each client.

Why Do Most Real Estate Agents Fail? The 9 Reasons

1. Money Runs Out Before the First Cheque

This is the reason that ends the most careers early. Costs start the day you register. Your first commission may not arrive for months, because you are normally paid after closing, and closing often comes weeks or months after the offer firms up.

Typical first-year costs in Ontario include:

  • RECO registration: $306 for a two-year term today. On October 27, 2026, RECO confirmed that registration fees return to 2022 levels plus 2.1% inflation on January 1, 2027, which makes it $398.
  • Mandatory insurance: The RECO insurance program (errors and omissions, deposit and commission protection) is billed every year. It was $500 plus tax per agent for the September 2025 to August 2026 term, so check RECO for the current amount. If it goes unpaid, your registration is suspended and you cannot trade.
  • Real estate board and association dues: These vary by board, so ask for the current amounts before you sign anything.
  • Brokerage costs: Splits, desk fees and transaction fees differ widely between brokerages. Get the full picture in writing.
  • Running costs: Car, phone, signs, marketing and software.

Before you start, add up a full year of business costs plus your household bills. That number tells you how long your savings will carry you. Our guide to saving for a rainy day shows how agents build that cushion and protect it once commissions start.

2. There Is No Plan, Only Hope

Most new agents come from salaried jobs where a manager set the targets. In real estate you are self-employed, so a quiet Tuesday stays quiet unless you fill it.

A useful first-year plan fits on one page:

  • Income target: What you need after splits, fees and tax.
  • Deal target: How many closed deals produce that income.
  • Activity target: How many conversations and appointments lead to one deal for you. Start with a guess and correct it with your own numbers by month three.
  • Runway: How many months your savings cover.

Agents who skip this step judge themselves only by closed deals. In the first few months that number is often zero, and the plan is what tells you whether you are on track anyway.

3. Leads Come From One Place, Then Stop

Friends and family produce the first deal for many agents. Then the list runs dry. Agents who last mix several channels and track which ones work.

Common channels for a new agent:

  • Sphere of influence: Regular, useful contact with people who already know you.
  • Open houses: Ask experienced agents in your office if you can host theirs.
  • Farming: Steady mail, door-knocking or local content for one neighbourhood.
  • Online content: Short local videos and posts that answer buyer and seller questions.

For a fuller list with free and paid options, see these real estate lead sources for Canadian agents.

4. Follow-Up Falls Apart

Most people you meet are not ready to move this month. They might be ready in eight months, and they will call whoever stayed in touch. New agents lose many of these future clients simply because nothing reminded them to follow up.

A CRM fixes most of this. Log every contact, note what the person wants and set the next reminder before you hang up. A short, helpful message every few weeks works better than a sales pitch twice a year.

5. The First Deal Takes Longer Than Expected

Many new agents expect a sale in month one. In practice, a buyer you meet in the spring may not firm up until summer, and then the deal still has to close before you are paid. Several dry months in a row are normal, and they knock confidence hard.

Judge your early months on activity you control: calls made, open houses held, appointments booked. Those numbers lead to deals later.

6. Part-Time Never Becomes Full-Time

Keeping a day job lowers money stress, and plenty of agents start this way. The trade-off is availability. Buyers want evening and weekend showings, and sellers expect quick answers. If you reply the next day, another agent may already have the client.

If you start part-time, write down the date or income level at which you will switch to full-time. Without a set point, many part-time agents stay stuck at a few deals a year.

7. Learning Stops at the Exam

Completing Humber’s pre-registration phase and registering with RECO lets you trade. It does not teach you how to price a home, run a listing presentation or handle multiple offers.

Ontario also ties your registration to ongoing education:

  • Post-registration education: New salespersons must complete a compliance course plus two electives within two years of registering. RECO says this is mandatory to renew at the end of the first two-year cycle.
  • Continuing education: After that, every two-year cycle requires two mandatory update courses and two electives to renew.

Missing these deadlines can end a career on paperwork alone. Book the post-registration courses in your first few months.

8. They Try to Figure It Out Alone

Early mistakes on pricing, offers and client expectations are expensive. They cost far less when an experienced agent checks your work first. When you compare brokerages to find the best company for real estate careers in Canada for you, ask how newer agents actually get help on live deals. You can see one example in this overview of first-year support for new agents.

9. Burnout Arrives Before the Results

New agents often say yes to every showing request and answer messages at midnight because they fear losing the client. That pace is hard to keep up for long. Some agents quit just as their pipeline starts to pay off.

Set work hours, batch admin tasks and take real time off each week. This guide to real estate agent work-life balance covers boundaries, automation and support systems that keep the job sustainable.

RE/MAX Millennium – Join CTA

Grow Your Real Estate Career at RE/MAX Millennium

Get hands-on training, full marketing and admin support, and access to a powerhouse network across the GTA.

Warning Signs to Watch in Your First Six Months

Warning signWhat it usually meansWhat to do this week
No written income or deal target by month twoThe business is driftingWrite the one-page plan above
Savings cover less than three monthsHigh risk of quitting earlyCut costs, extend your runway or set a part-time exit date
Fewer than five new conversations a weekWeak lead flowAdd one channel and track it
Leads go quiet after the first callNo follow-up systemSet up a CRM with reminders
Post-registration courses not bookedRenewal at riskBook the compliance course
No day off in the past two weeksBurnout riskBlock fixed off-hours in your calendar

What a First Commission Really Pays: An Ontario Example

New agents often picture the full commission landing in their account. Here is how one deal can shrink. All numbers below are illustrative. In Ontario, the commission is agreed between the client and the brokerage and is not set by RECO, and every brokerage agreement is different.

StepIllustrative amount
Sale price$900,000
Commission to your side at an example 2.5%$22,500
Example 80/20 split with your brokerageYou keep $18,000 before fees
HST at 13% on your $18,000 share$2,340 that you charge your brokerage and send to the CRA once you are registered for HST, so it is not income you keep
Income tax and CPPNot withheld, so you set money aside yourself

A few rules shape that last line:

  • HST registration: The CRA says you stop being a small supplier once your taxable sales pass $30,000 in a single calendar quarter or over four consecutive quarters. After that you must register and charge HST.
  • CPP: Self-employed people pay both halves of CPP. For 2026 that is 11.9% of earnings between $3,500 and $74,600.
  • Timing: You are usually paid after closing, so a deal written in May might pay in July or later.

For context, Job Bank lists a median annual income of $62,400 for residential real estate agents in Ontario, based on 2021 Census data. That median includes experienced agents, so first-year income is often well below it.

How Do Real Estate Agents Sustain a Career in the Initial Years?

Agents who make it through year one usually follow a simple routine and stick to it. Here is a practical version.

Months 1 to 3:

  • Shadow real work: Sit in on showings, listing appointments and offer presentations.
  • Tell everyone: Contact your whole network and say clearly what you now do.
  • Book your courses: Schedule the RECO post-registration compliance course.
  • Set up systems: A CRM, a weekly calendar routine and an expense tracker.

Months 4 to 6:

  • Host open houses: Aim for one most weekends.
  • Choose a focus: One neighbourhood, property type or client group you can serve well.
  • Track your numbers: Conversations, appointments, signed clients and deals.

Months 7 to 12:

  • Review monthly: Compare results with your plan and adjust activity, not the goal.
  • Ask for referrals: Every closed client and every warm contact.
  • Decide on part-time: If you are still part-time, check your switch date.

The brokerage you pick affects every one of these steps. When you compare options, look past the split and ask about training schedules, marketing help, technology and access to experienced agents. Those factors shape how much help you actually get in year one.

At RE/MAX Millennium, new agents get personalized business planning, onboarding, training and coaching, an in-house marketing team that creates flyers, social media posts and email campaigns, and tools to help manage leads. New agents are also paired with experienced mentors as part of onboarding. If you are thinking about joining RE/MAX as a new agent, you can see what that support includes before you decide.

Why Do Real Estate Agents Quit Even When They Are Doing OK?

Not everyone who leaves is failing. Some agents close a handful of deals and still walk away. The usual reasons:

  • Uneven income: A strong quarter followed by an empty one strains a household budget.
  • Market cycles: When GTA sales drop, as they did in October 2026 (down 7.9% year over year, per TRREB), there are fewer deals to go around.
  • Lifestyle fit: Evening and weekend work does not suit every family.
  • A salaried offer: After a slow stretch, a steady paycheque elsewhere can win.

None of these mean the agent did something wrong. They are reasons to plan savings, schedule and expectations before you start, so one slow season does not decide your career.

Frequently Asked Questions

What percentage of real estate agents fail in the first year?

No reliable official figure exists for Canada or Ontario. The best Ontario proxies are RECO’s 6,457 terminations against 4,671 new applications in 2025, and the 52.7% of TRREB agents who closed no deals that year.

Is real estate a hard career to start?

Yes, for most people the first year is the hardest. Income is irregular and you build a client base from scratch. It usually gets easier once referrals and repeat clients start to come in.

How long does it take a new agent to close a first deal?

It varies, and no Ontario body tracks it. A buyer often takes weeks or months to firm up an offer, and you are usually paid only after the deal closes, so several months without a cheque is common for new agents.

How much money should a new agent save before starting?

Enough to cover your household bills and business costs for several months with no commission. Add up registration, insurance, board dues, brokerage costs and marketing, then multiply your monthly total by the number of months you expect before your first closing.

Can you succeed as a part-time real estate agent?

Some agents do, especially at the start. It is harder because clients expect quick replies and flexible showing times. Setting a date to move to full-time helps.

What do successful new agents do differently?

They write a plan, track their numbers, follow up with every lead and keep learning after registration. They also choose a brokerage whose training and support match what they need.

What happens if you do not finish post-registration education in Ontario?

You cannot renew your RECO registration at the end of your first two-year cycle. Humber gives a maximum of 24 months to finish the post-registration phase, so start early.

Build a First Year That Lasts

The numbers above show how thin the margin is: more than half of TRREB agents closed nothing in 2025. A cash cushion, a weekly lead routine, a CRM and someone to check your deals are the parts you can set up before your first day.

If regular coaching would help you through year one, look at RE/MAX Millennium’s training: 3 to 5 sessions a week on marketing, pre-construction, legal, mortgage and sales topics, monthly legal training and 500+ training videos. Book a meeting to see how it fits your first-year plan.

This article is general information only. Speak with a licensed accountant, lawyer or other professional about your own tax, legal or financial situation.

RE/MAX Millennium – Join CTA

Grow Your Real Estate Career at RE/MAX Millennium

Get hands-on training, full marketing and admin support, and access to a powerhouse network across the GTA.

Recent Posts

Book a Confidential Meeting with our Broker of Record & understand How RE/MAX Millennium can Help Scale up your Business

Book a Confidential Meeting with our
Broker of Record

Download this PDF to enhance your knowledge on Real Estate & Technology